inquiry on inquiry
It was earlier this year when I started looking for a research topic related to chemical education. There's a well-known American Chemical Society journal, colloquially refered to as JChemEd. I visited other ACS journals regularly, so it was without much thought that I opened JChemEd to flip through their just-submitted articles. One in the first five caught my eye, with its title seeming almost oxymoronic.
"Ungrading in a High-Enrollment Second-Year Organic Chemistry Teaching Laboratory," sounded so unusual. It was the first time I ever heard the shocking term "Ungrading". Scanning through the list of authors, I was shocked again. Third author was Emma Davy, the Chem department chair at Quest, an incredible educator I consider a mentor. If Emma was on it, I knew it must mean something rigorous. After Quest, Emma worked as a chemistry education specialist in the UBC chemistry department, where this work was carried out.
Ungrading is an alternative assessment practice that gives students a reward - in the form of slightly higher grades - for going back through their work and assessing it themselves. In my conception of it, I would mark tests with prodigious feedback about what was wrong and where mistakes were made. In a secret ledger, I would tabulate a grade based on the feedback. Then marked (but ungraded) exams would be returned to students. It would then be up to them to go through the feedback and try and estimate their own grades. They themselves would have to consider how important their mistakes were, without a number or letter attached. If their calculated grade fell within one standard deviation of the grade I had recorded, they would get an automatic boost, for example from a B to a B+. It would turn every assessment into a formative one.
Grades are a powerful lever to manipulate behavior. If we have the power to decide when to release the feedback that many students desperately desire, we should use it to extract something greater, to make all the work we do grading truly worthwhile. To force students to learn from their mistakes. To truly look at them and not just focus on the letter on the front page.
Thought provoking and extremely interesting!
ReplyDelete